|
 |
| ORIGINAL ARTICLE |
|
| Year : 2017 | Volume
: 16
| Issue : 2 | Page : 46-51 |
|
|
Burden of informal caregivers of stroke survivors: Validation of the Zarit burden interview in an African population
Frank Aiwansoba Imarhiagbe1, AU Asemota1, BA Oripelaye1, JE Akpekpe1, AA Owolabi1, AO Abidakun1, FM Akemokwe1, VO Ogundare1, AL Azeez2, JO Osakue2
1 Department of Medicine, Neurology Unit, University of Benin Teaching Hospital, Benin City, Nigeria
2 Department of Surgery, Division of Neurological Surgery, University of Benin Teaching Hospital, Benin City, Nigeria
| Date of Web Publication | 27-Apr-2017 |
Correspondence Address:
Frank Aiwansoba Imarhiagbe
Department of Medicine, Neurology Unit, University of Benin Teaching Hospital, Benin City
Nigeria
 Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None  | Check |
DOI: 10.4103/aam.aam_213_16
 Abstract | | |
Background: Informal care giving can be burdensome particularly where the option of institutionalized informal care scarcely exist. Objective: To look at the burden of informal caregivers of stroke survivors using the Zarit burden interview (ZBI). Method: 64 stroke survivors were assessed for demographics of age, gender, duration of follow-up since discharged from in-patient care, modified Rankin score at the time of discharge and at the time of evaluation for this study and the most important informal care giver at home was also assessed for whether care giving was telling on their health or life in any negative way. All the caregivers were subsequently assessed with the ZBI. Results: Mean age of most important informal care givers was 40.67 ± 14.27 years and the sex distribution was 33(51.6%) female and 29(45.4%) males. 21(32.8%) reported that caregiving was a health burden. Mean ZBI scores were significantly higher (30.19 ± 14.81 vs 20.30 ± 12.96, P < 0.01) in those that reported that caregiving was telling on their health. ZBI overall rating of burden of caregiving was also significantly associated with whether caregiving was telling on the health of caregiver (P = 0.01) and also symmetrically agreed with whether the burden of caregiving was telling on health (k = 0.33, P< 0.01). The sensitivity and specificity of ZBI were 70% and 68.4% respectively on ROC statistics (AUC = 0.67, P = 0.017). Conclusion: Reported burden of informal caregiving of about 33% is in our opinion huge. The moderate sensitivity and specificity of the ZBI means it could be safely used in the population studied.
| Abstract in French | | |
Résumé
Contexte: La prise en charge informelle peut être lourde, surtout lorsque l'option des soins informels institutionnalisés n'existe pratiquement pas. Objectif: Examiner le fardeau des soignants informels des survivants d'AVC en utilisant l'interview Zarit fardeau (ZBI). Méthode: 64 survivants d'un AVC ont été évalués pour Les données démographiques relatives à l'âge, au sexe, à la durée du suivi depuis le congé des patients hospitalisés, au score de Rankin modifié au moment du Le moment de l'évaluation de cette étude et le plus important dispensateur de soins informels à domicile a également été évalué pour savoir si La santé ou la vie de manière négative. Tous les soignants ont ensuite été évalués avec la ZBI. Résultats: Âge moyen des soins informels les plus importants Des donneurs était de 40,67 ± 14,27 ans et la répartition par sexe était de 33 (51,6%) femmes et de 29 (45,4%) hommes. 21 (32,8%) ont déclaré que la prestation de soins charge. Les scores moyens de ZBI étaient significativement plus élevés (30,19 ± 14,81 vs 20,30 ± 12,96, P < 0,01) chez ceux qui indiquaient que les soins donnaient santé. ZBI évaluation globale du fardeau de caregiving a également été significativement associée à savoir si la prestation de soins était révélateur sur la santé de l'aidant naturel (P = 0,01) et aussi symétriquement d'accord avec la question de savoir si le fardeau de la prestation de soins était révélateur sur la santé (k = 0,33, P < 0,01). La sensibilité et la spécificité De ZBI étaient 70% et 68.4% respectivement sur les statistiques de ROC (AUC = 0.67, P = 0.017). Conclusion: Le fardeau de la prestation de soins informels 33% est à notre avis énorme. La sensibilité et la spécificité modérées de la ZBI signifient qu'elle pourrait être utilisée en toute sécurité dans la population étudiée.
Mots-clés: Fardeau, aidant, accident vasculaire cérébral, survivants, Zarit Burden Interview Keywords: Burden, caregiver, stroke, survivors, Zarit Burden Interview
How to cite this article:
Imarhiagbe FA, Asemota A U, Oripelaye B A, Akpekpe J E, Owolabi A A, Abidakun A O, Akemokwe F M, Ogundare V O, Azeez A L, Osakue J O. Burden of informal caregivers of stroke survivors: Validation of the Zarit burden interview in an African population. Ann Afr Med 2017;16:46-51 |
How to cite this URL:
Imarhiagbe FA, Asemota A U, Oripelaye B A, Akpekpe J E, Owolabi A A, Abidakun A O, Akemokwe F M, Ogundare V O, Azeez A L, Osakue J O. Burden of informal caregivers of stroke survivors: Validation of the Zarit burden interview in an African population. Ann Afr Med [serial online] 2017 [cited 2023 May 30];16:46-51. Available from: https://www.annalsafrmed.org/text.asp?2017/16/2/46/205277 |
| Introduction | |  |
Informal caregivers are non-medically trained persons who offer supportive care to persons who have medical conditions that affect their ability to carry out basic activities of daily living (ADL). Their role(s) in caring for the invalid can be huge and complementary in chronic conditions like in those recuperating from a manifest stroke with disability severe enough to affect ADL.[1] It is estimated that there are about 60 million stroke survivors in the world and about a third to two-thirds of these are dependent with a modified Rankin score of 3 and above.[2] The disability-adjusted life year, which is the sum of the number of years lost to ill-health and the number of years lost from life expectancy, is higher in stroke survivors and stroke is also the leading cause of non-accidental chronic disability.[3]
Caring for stroke survivors informally can be burdensome and particularly so in climes where institutionalized informal care is not readily available.[1],[4],[5],[6] The corollary is that informal care devolves on close relatives of the invalid. Informal caregiving could cause man-hour losses, physical, mental, and emotional strain and in extreme cases a burnt-out feeling in the caregiver.[7],[8],[9]
There are well-established tools for the assessment of informal caregivers' burden, and this has been done in western and other climes. The Zarit Burden Interview (ZBI) is an example of a widely used tool for this purpose.[10],[11],[12] Although originally used in the assessment of caregivers' burden in caring for the elderly, its use has been expanded since it was first published about four decades ago.[13] ZBI is originally a 22-item tool that is grouped into six sections which document the informal caregiver's assessment of the burden of caregiving. It also has a second part that allows for global rating of the burden of care, thereby offering the user both quantitative and qualitative assessment of the burden of caregiving. Several short versions that are user-friendly have been developed from the original unabridged version [Appendix for ZBI] [Additional file 1] .
This study assessed informal caregivers' burden in stroke survivors in a neurology outpatient clinic in sub-Saharan Africa using the ZBI and validated it in the process.
| Methods | | |
Sixty-four stroke survivors on follow-up in a neurology outpatient clinic were consecutively assessed with a questionnaire for demographics of age, gender, level of education and stroke type, duration of follow-up since discharged from inpatient care, modified Rankin score at the time of discharge and modified Rankin score at the time of evaluation in the clinic for this study and the most important informal caregiver at home was also assessed for age, gender, level of education, relationship to patient, whether caregiver is on stipend or not, duration of care, whether there are other caregivers(s) or not, number of hours of caregiving in 24 h. Furthermore, the caregiver was assessed for whether caregiving was telling on their health or life in any negative way and whether they wanted to be relieved of the caregiving duties or not.
All the caregivers were subsequently assessed with the ZBI, and their scores were recorded in a pro forma. The study was approved by the research and ethics committee of the institution where the study was done.
Data were entered into a spreadsheet and exported to SPSS version 21. Data were presented as proportions and percentages for categorical and discrete variables and mean and standard deviations and median and interquartile range (IQR) for normally and skewed continuous variables, respectively. Data were compared between caregivers that reported that caregiving was telling on their health and those that reported it was not. Categorical variables were compared with Pearson's Chi-square and continuous variables with independent t-test or median test as appropriate. Symmetric agreement between ZBI score and ZBI global rating and the effect of caregiving on health or life as reported by caregiver was tested on crosstab kappa statistics. The sensitivity and specificity of ZBI score were tested on receiver operated characteristics curve. P< 0.05 was taken as statistically significant for all tests.
| Results | | |
The mean age of stroke survivors was 66.11 ± 11.60 years, and sex distribution was 21 (32.8%) females and 43 (67.2%) males. 57 (89.1%) had cerebral infarct, and 7 (10.9%) had cerebral hemorrhage. The median duration of follow-up since discharge from in-patient care was 330 days, (IQR 730–39). Median modified Rankin score at discharge and at the time of evaluation in clinic were 4 (IQR 5–3) and 3 (IQR 4–3), respectively [Table 1].
Mean age of most important informal caregivers was 40.67 ± 14.27 years and the sex distribution was 33 (51.6%) females and 29 (48.4%) males. Only 4 (6.2%) of caregivers were not biologically related to the stroke survivors; 14 (21.9%) of caregivers were on stipends; 21 (32.8%) reported that caregiving was telling on their health; and 11 (17.2%) reported that they wanted relief from the burden of caregiving [Table 2].
Data were subsequently compared between caregivers who reported that caregiving was telling on their health and those that reported it was not.
Caregivers who reported that burden of caregiving was telling on their health compared to those that did not report, did not differ significantly in age (P = 0.17), sex (P = 0.61), educational level (P = 0.16), duration of caregiving (P = 0.32), number of hours of caregiving per day (P = 0.74), and modified Rankin score of stroke survivors both at discharge and at the time of evaluation for the study (P = 0.60), and (P = 0.86), respectively [Table 3]. | Table 3: Comparing characteristics of caregivers who reported that caregiving was telling on their health versus those that reported otherwise
Click here to view |
However, mean ZBI score was significantly higher in those that reported that caregiving was telling on their health (30.19 ± 14.81 vs. 20.30 ± 12.96; P < 0.01) [Table 3]. ZBI global rating of burden of caregiving symmetrically agreed with whether the burden of caregiving was telling on health or not (k = 0.33, P < 0.01) [Table 4]. | Table 4: Symmetric agreement between Zarit Burden interview global rating of burden of caregiving and caregivers' report of effect of caregiving on health
Click here to view |
The sensitivity and specificity of ZBI numerical scale were70% and 68.4%, respectively, area under the curve = 0.69, P = 0.01 [Figure 1]. | Figure 1: ROC curve showing sensitivity and specificity of Zarit Burden Interview
Click here to view |
| Discussion | | |
The mean age of the stroke survivors and the preponderance of males are consistent with similar studies as well as the predominance of cerebral infarcts as the stroke type.[14] The long median duration of follow-up (330 days) and higher median Rankin score at the time of discharge and evaluation in clinic for the stroke survivors are remarkable as they provided ample opportunity to assess the burden of informal caregivers in predominantly dependent (Rankin score of 3 and above) subjects. The burden of informal caregiving is known to be affected by the level of dependence of the subject being cared for and also by the duration of caregiving.[1],[13],[15],[16] The relative younger age of the caregivers and the female sex preponderance are also noteworthy; it may be reflective of the age range of fitness of the individuals who can offer caregiving and the general tendency to have more females in informal caregiving and home nursing.[13],[15],[17] That the majority of caregivers were biologically related to the stroke survivors is indicative of the relative scarcity of institutionalized informal caregiving in the clime in which the study was carried out. Institutionalized informal caregiving scarcely exists in sub-Saharan Africa hence caregiving by biologic relatives is the rule rather than the exception.[18],[19] This is corroborated by the small number (about a fifth) of caregivers that received stipends for caregiving.
Remarkably, about a third (32.1%) of caregivers reported that the burden of caregiving was telling on their health and about a fifth (17.2%) said they wanted to be relieved of their caregiving duties. The proportion of those that reported that caregiving was affecting their health in a negative way is huge in our opinion, and particularly so in a clime where social security like health insurance is almost not existent for the large majority. The social effect of this is that the caregivers have to seek help on their own and this adds to the societal burden of disease.
The absence of significant differences between the demographic characteristics of age, sex, educational level, and modified Rankin scores of stroke survivors whose caregivers reported that caregiving was telling on their health and those that reported it was not, suggests that factors inherent in the caregivers might be more prevalent in determining the effect of caregiving on health in this study.[19] However, related studies have shown that the age, sex, educational level, and level of functional independence as measured by modified Rankin score of the stroke survivor and the age and educational level of the caregiver and hours per day of caregiving are determinants of the burden of caregiving.[14],[20],[21]
It is noteworthy that ZBI measure of caregivers' burden was numerically and qualitatively (global rating) higher in caregivers that reported that caregiving was telling on their health. This assesses the burden of caregiving as reported by the caregiver. The 33% symmetric agreement between ZBI global rating of the burden of caregiving and caregivers' assessment of the effect of caregiving on their health may appear low, but that it achieved statistical significance deserves to be mentioned. Although the sensitivity and specificity of ZBI score were significantly moderate (70 and 68.4%, respectively), it, however, shows that it could safely be used to objectively assess the burden of caregiving as have been profusely done in similar studies in other climes.[22] Its use in populations of similar composition is therefore recommended.
The small sample size of study participants is an obvious limitation in this work.
Acknowledgment
We acknowledge the contributions of other members and support staff of the neurology outpatient department of the University of Benin Teaching Hospital, Benin City, Nigeria.
Financial support and sponsorship
Nil.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References | | |
| 1. | Rigby H, Gubitz G, Eskes G, Reidy Y, Christian C, Grover V, et al. Caring for stroke survivors: Baseline and 1-year determinants of caregiver burden. Int J Stroke 2009;4:152-8.  |
| 2. | Hong KS. Disability-adjusted life years analysis: Implications for stroke research. J Clin Neurol 2011;7:109-14. |
| 3. | Lemogoum D, Degaute JP, Bovet P. Stroke prevention, treatment, and rehabilitation in sub-saharan Africa. Am J Prev Med 2005;29 5 Suppl 1:95-101. |
| 4. | Sales E. Family burden and quality of life. Qual Life Res 2003;12 Suppl 1:33-41. |
| 5. | Camak DJ. Addressing the burden of stroke caregivers: A literature review. J Clin Nurs 2015;24:2376-82. |
| 6. | Saban KL, Sherwood PR, DeVon HA, Hynes DM. Measures of psychological stress and physical health in family caregivers of stroke survivors: A literature review. J Neurosci Nurs 2010;42:128-38. |
| 7. | Carod-Artal FJ, Egido JA. Quality of life after stroke: The importance of a good recovery. Cerebrovasc Dis 2009;27 Suppl 1:204-14. |
| 8. | King RB, Semik PE. Stroke caregiving: Difficult times, resource use, and needs during the first 2 years. J Gerontol Nurs 2006;32:37-44. |
| 9. | Gbiri CA, Olawale OA, Isaac SO. Stroke management: Informal caregivers' burdens and strians of caring for stroke survivors. Ann Phys Rehabil Med 2015;58:98-103. |
| 10. | Gort AM, Mingot M, Gomez X, Soler T, Torres G, Sacristán O, et al. Use of the Zarit scale for assessing caregiver burden and collapse in caregiving at home in dementias. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2007;22:957-62. |
| 11. | Van Durme T, Macq J, Jeanmart C, Gobert M. Tools for measuring the impact of informal caregiving of the elderly: A literature review. Int J Nurs Stud 2012;49:490-504. |
| 12. | Sonoda S, Shirayama Y, Sakamoto R, Nagai S, Sakurai S. Factors influencing the Zarit Burden Interview in a Japanese community: Activities of daily living and depressive state. Int J Phys Med Rehabil 2014;2:216. |
| 13. | Bhattacharjee M, Vairale J, Gawali K, Dalal PM. Factors affecting burden on caregivers of stroke survivors: Population-based study in Mumbai (India). Ann Indian Acad Neurol 2012;15:113-9. [ PUBMED] [Full text] |
| 14. | Imarhiagbe FA, Abidakun A. Functional motor recovery in stroke survivors-determinants in a sub-Saharan African stroke unit. East Afr Med J 2014;91:119-24. |
| 15. | Ogunlana MO, Olumide OD, Oyewo OS, Odole OC, Ogunsan MO. Quality of life and burden of informal caregivers of stroke survivors. Hong Kong Physiother J 2014;32:6-12. |
| 16. | Choi-Kwon S, Kim HS, Kwon SU, Kim JS. Factors affecting the burden on caregivers of stroke survivors in South Korea. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2005;86:1043-8. |
| 17. | Yang X, Hao Y, George SM, Wang L. Factors associated with health-related quality of life among Chinese caregivers of the older adults living in the community: A cross-sectional study. Health Qual Life Outcomes 2012;10:143. |
| 18. | Fatoye FO, Komolafe MA, Adewuya AO, Fatoye GK. Emotional distress and self-reported quality of life among primary caregivers of stroke survivors in Nigeria. East Afr Med J 2006;83:271-9. |
| 19. | Vincent-Onabajo G, Ali A, Hamzat T. Quality of life of Nigerian informal caregivers of community-dwelling stroke survivors. Scand J Caring Sci 2013;27:977-82. |
| 20. | Scholte Op Reimer WJ, de Haan RJ, Rijnders PT, Limburg M, van den Bos GA. The burden of caregiving in partners of long-term stroke survivors. Stroke 1998;29:1605-11. |
| 21. | Nimnual C, Rapin C, Doldao P, Chompunut S. Family burden of stroke patients in Rayong Hospital Thailand. Int J Appl Psychol 2016;6:15-9. |
| 22. | Schreiner AS, Morimoto T, Arai Y, Zarit S. Assessing family caregiver's mental health using a statistically derived cut-off score for the Zarit Burden Interview. Aging Ment Health 2006;10:107-11. |
[Figure 1]
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]
| This article has been cited by | | 1 |
Stroke Rehabilitation in Low- and Middle-Income Countries |
|
| Grace Kayola, Mataa M. Mataa, Melody Asukile, Lorraine Chishimba, Mashina Chomba, Dominique Mortel, Aparna Nutakki, Stanley Zimba, Deanna Saylor | | American Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation. 2023; 102(2S): S24 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 2 |
The Burden and Quality of life of Caregivers of Stroke Survivors with Cognitive Impairment in Selected Healthcare Facilities in Anambra State, Nigeria |
|
| Uchenna Prosper Okonkwo, Chukwuebuka Fortune Agbo, Sam Chidi Ibeneme, Emeka Sylvester Igwe, Christopher Olusegun Akosile, Ifeoma Uchenna Onwuakagba, Okoye Chiebuka Emmanuel, Stanley Monday Maduagwu, Elochukwu Fortune Ezenwankwo, Echezona Nelson Ekechukwu | | Gerontology and Geriatric Medicine. 2022; 8: 2333721422 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 3 |
Burdens on caregivers of patients with stroke during a pandemic: relationships with support satisfaction, psychological distress, and fear of COVID-19 |
|
| Chieh-hsiu Liu, Yi-Jung Chen, Jung-Sheng Chen, Chia-Wei Fan, Meng-Tsang Hsieh, Chung-Ying Lin, Amir H. Pakpour | | BMC Geriatrics. 2022; 22(1) | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 4 |
Typology of informal carers providing care to family members after cerebrovascular accident |
|
| Miroslav Paulícek, Lenka Krhutová, Iva Kuzníková, Kamila Vondroušová, Iva Tichá, Hana Lukšová, Petra Anna-Marie Blahová, Veronika Valoušková, Marcela Dabrowská, Jarmila Kristiníková, Petr Šaloun | | Kontakt. 2021; 23(3): 200 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 5 |
Caring for a Loved One with Stroke in Lomé, Togo: an Intersectional Framework |
|
| Ami R. Moore, Adobea Yaa Owusu, Sarah Moore, Rebekah Knight | | Ageing International. 2021; | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 6 |
Sobrecarga del cuidador con relación al estado cognitivo y la dependencia en las actividades de la vida diaria de pacientes con accidente cerebrovascular: un estudio transversal en la República Dominicana |
|
| Víctor Sánchez Silverio, Vanesa Abuín Porras, Isabel Rodríguez Costa | | Revista Científica de la Sociedad Española de Enfermería Neurológica. 2021; | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 7 |
Caregiver burden in relation to cognitive status and dependence on activities of daily living in stroke patients: A cross-sectional study in the Dominican Republic |
|
| Víctor Sánchez Silverio, Vanesa Abuín Porras, Isabel Rodríguez Costa | | Revista Científica de la Sociedad de Enfermería Neurológica (English ed.). 2021; | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 8 |
Caregiving burden and mental health problems among family caregivers of people with dementia in rural Uganda |
|
| Herbert E. Ainamani, Paul E. Alele, Godfrey Z. Rukundo, Samuel Maling, Edith K. Wakida, Celestino Obua, Alexander C. Tsai | | Global Mental Health. 2020; 7 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 9 |
Client-centred practice in occupational therapy after stroke: A systematic review |
|
| María Rodríguez-Bailón, Laura López-González, Jose Antonio Merchán-Baeza | | Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy. 2020; : 1 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 10 |
Depression and quality of life among family caregivers of Stroke Survivors in Ghana: The role of social support |
|
| DoreenAsantewa Abeasi | | Archives of Mental Health. 2020; 21(2): 83 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | | | 11 |
Effect of a tailored multidimensional intervention on the care burden among family caregivers of stroke survivors: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial |
|
| Mahmoud Ahmed Elsheikh, Michiko Moriyama, Md Moshiur Rahman, Mayumi Kako, Ahmed Hashem El-Monshed, Mohamed Zoromba, Hamada Zehry, Maha Hazem Khalil, Mostafa Amr | | BMJ Open. 2020; 10(12): e041637 | | [Pubmed] | [DOI] | |
|
 |
|
|
|
